David Gordon Green's Halloween trilogy, a reboot of the iconic slasher franchise, has been a polarizing affair, with fans and critics alike divided over its execution. While the films were financially successful, the quality and coherence of the story took a hit with each installment, leaving audiences with a sense of unease and a longing for the franchise's former glory.
The trilogy's central issue lies in its lack of a cohesive long-term plan. Each film introduces new elements and twists, often without proper setup or resolution, leading to a disjointed narrative. The character arcs, particularly those of Laurie Strode and her granddaughter Allison, are inconsistent and confusing, leaving viewers with a sense of betrayal and frustration.
One of the most glaring examples of this is the character of Corey Cunningham, who overshadowing Michael Myers in Halloween Ends. Corey's presence feels like a bizarre distraction, and his character's arc is rushed and ill-conceived. The trilogy also struggles with tonal consistency, with humor and serious moments often clashing, as seen in the awkward 'banh mi sandwich' scene in Halloween (2018).
The trilogy's attempt to redefine Michael Myers as a non-supernatural force of evil is another point of contention. While the idea is intriguing, it contradicts the very nature of the character as portrayed in the original films. Michael's supernatural abilities, such as surviving extreme physical trauma and displaying superhuman strength, are integral to his mystique and the franchise's appeal.
Despite these issues, the trilogy's kills are a highlight, with Michael Myers becoming an unstoppable force of terror. The rewatch value of the films is a testament to the enduring appeal of the character and the franchise's ability to deliver thrilling moments. However, the overall lack of a clear vision and the constant reworking of the narrative have left the Halloween franchise in a state of flux, with its future uncertain.
In conclusion, David Gordon Green's Halloween trilogy, while financially successful, has failed to capture the essence of the original franchise. The lack of a cohesive plan, inconsistent character arcs, and tonal inconsistencies have left a bitter taste in the mouths of fans. As the franchise continues to evolve, it is crucial for the next creative team to approach it with a stronger long-term vision and a deeper understanding of the horror genre's nuances.
